Mary J Cottage Bakery, LLC

Savor the Homemade Goodness

Delicious baked goods made with love at Mary J Cottage Bakery. Indulge in the warmth and flavor of every bite. 
Order Now

Delightful Baked Goods

Explore our selection of freshly baked goods that bring warmth and flavor.
Zeppole di San Giuseppe (St. Josephs Day Pastries)

St. Joseph's or Zeppole

Custard filled Italian Pastry
Brown Butter Southern Banana Bread

Brown Butter Banana Walnut Bread
Brown Butter Southern Banana Bread

"Twix" Cookies

Shortbread cookies topped with caramel and chocolate
Brown Butter Southern Banana Bread

Pineapple Upside Down Cake
Pistachio Specialty Cake

Pistachio Cake

Layers of Pistachio Cake filled with a Pistachio moose and topped with a honey whipped cream
Ultimate Chocolate Cake

Ultimate Chocolate Cake

Layers of Chocolate Cake filled with chocolate mousse, frosted with a chocolate ganache frosting and chocolate shavings.
Italian Run Specialty Cake

Italian Rum Cake

Rum-Soaked vanilla cake filled with vanilla and chocolate custard topped with Vanilla cream frosting slivered almonds and chocolate shavings
Italian Run Specialty Cake

Pineapple Poundcake

This butter poundcake is filled with Pineapple and topped with a vanilla glaze.

Cookie platters

Fresh Buttery Cookies

Cookie Box

Fresh baked cookies

Sunday Cake

Layer of Banana and Strawberry cake filled with a pineapple filling topped with a vanilla whipped ganache and chocolate ganache and maraschino cherries 

Fruit Tarts 

Vanilla Custard filled on top of a butter crust topped with fresh fruit beautifully arranged 

Single Serve Lemon Meringue Pie

Lemon Filled Pie with a lightly toasted meringue 

Carmel Apple Cupcakes

Cinnamon apple cupcakes with a Carmel cinnamon frosting drizzled with caramel sauce.

Pineapple Crunch Pie

Fresh Pineapple baked into this delicious pie, topped with a cinnamon crumble topping.

Why Choose Us

Discover why Mary J Cottage Bakery is the perfect choice for your cravings.
Muffin A line styled icon from Orion Icon Library.

Freshly Baked Goods

Orders are baked fresh with simple ingredients by order. Nothing is premade.
Cake A line styled icon from Orion Icon Library.

Wide Selection

From cookies, cakes to decadent pies, we cater to all tastes.
Balloon Whisk A line styled icon from Orion Icon Library.

Local Delivery

Enjoy our mouthwatering creations delivered fresh to your door!

Crafted Delights, Fresh from Home

Indulge in the delightful, home-baked goodness of Mary J Cottage Bakery. We pride ourselves on crafting fresh, delicious baked goods from scratch, bringing warmth and flavor to every bite. From cookies, pies, cakes, muffins, cupcakes, pastries our selection caters to all tastes. Conveniently located in Stratford, CT, we offer local delivery and shipping.
Our goal is to use fresh simple ingredients to create indulgent baked goods along with baked goods with dietary restrictions. 

Cake/Cupcake:

                Flavors

Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvette, Marble, ½ Vanilla – ½ Chocolate

                Choice of Fillings:

                                Regular: Pineapple, strawberry, Blueberry, Apple, Chocolate, Carmel Cream, Peach, Mango

                                Sugar Free: (with no added sugar) Pineapple, strawberry, Blueberry, Apple, Carmel Cream, Chocolate 

Specialty: Fall Harvest (pumpkin spiced cake with apples, pears, cranberries and topped with cinnamon frosting), Carrot Cake, Strawberry Shortcake, Twix, Snickers, Peanut Butter Cup, Ferraro Roche, Cannoli, Pistachio, Carmel Apple, Pineapple Upside-down Cake, Hummingbird Cake, Italian Rum Cake

                Choice of Frostings: Vanilla, Chocolate, Cinnamon 

 

Scones:

                           Blueberry/Lemon, Cranberry/Orange, Chocolate Chip, Cinnamon Apple

 

 Pies: 

 Flavors: Regular: Pecan, Apple, Lemon Meringue, Key Lime, Banana Cream, Chocolate Cream, Peanut Butter, Carmel Cream

No sugar: Sugar Free Pecan, No Sugar Added Apple, No Added Sugar Banana Cream, Sugar Free Chocolate Cream, Sugar Free Turtle

                                Specialty: Boston Cream, Banana Carmel, Carmel Apple, Peanut Butter Cup, Snickers

Muffins:

                Flavors: Walnut, Blueberry, Banana-Nut, Carrot Cake

                Specialty Flavors: Salted Carmel Apple, Orange-Cranberry, Nutella-Almond, Fall Harvest

                                                                                                                                                               

Miscellaneous:

                           Cookie Trays (Assorted) 

                           Brownies/Blondies 

                           Cinnamon Rolls 

                           Coffee Cakes 

                           Fruit Tarts

                          Flan

                            (call for pricing)

              Follow us on Facebook Mary J Cottage Bakery

                       Call to order 203-375-7342

                Located in Stratford, CT Area

 

Happy Customers

Read what our satisfied customers have to say about our delicious baked goods.
Samantha H.
Mary J Cottage Bakery is a true gem! The muffins are always fresh, and the flavors are unbeatable. Makes my mornings so much better.
David S.
Best cupcakes in Stratford! Every bite is a taste of home. I highly recommend their cookies too.
Linda M.
I ordered an assortment of baked goods for a family gathering, and everything was perfect. The brownies are absolutely delicious, and the scones were a hit!

Connect with Us

Find our contact details below to reach us.

Phone

Call us at 203-375-7342 to order

Indulge Today, Taste the Difference!

Satisfy your cravings with our freshly baked treats. Order Now to experience the homemade goodness of Mary J Cottage Bakery!